Skip to content
Deep Drawing · Metal Stamping · CNC Machining · Solenoid Valve Housings · Robotics & UAV Metal Parts · PPAP-Ready

Engineering Data · Failure Analysis

Why Does A Deep Drawn Part Crack At The Punch Radius?

Published October 25, 2026 · Balford Technical Team

A crack at the punch radius is the most common way a deep drawing job fails. It is also the one that gets blamed on the wrong thing most often, because the crack appears in the tool while the cause is usually in the draw ratio or the material. The punch radius is simply where the wall is thinnest and the load is highest, so it is where the part tells you first.

Why does a deep drawn part crack at the punch radius?

A crack at the punch radius means the material could not carry the load the punch put on it at that point. That is where a drawn wall is thinnest, because the metal that becomes the wall is pulled over the punch nose and stretched. Four things cause it, and they are worth checking in this order. The draw ratio comes first: if the blank diameter divided by the punch diameter exceeds roughly 1.8-2.0 for low carbon steel, 1.6-1.8 for stainless steel or 1.8-2.0 for pure iron, the reduction is beyond what a single draw can take and a second draw is needed. Second is the punch nose radius, which sets how concentrated the strain is. Third is the material's condition - grain direction, incoming hardness and prior cold work. Fourth is lubrication and friction. The first two are design decisions; the last two are process settings.

The four causes, in the order to check them

  • Draw ratio. Blank diameter divided by punch diameter. Above roughly 1.8-2.0 for low carbon steel, 1.6-1.8 for stainless and 1.8-2.0 for pure iron, one draw is asking too much and the part needs a second draw or an intermediate anneal.
  • Punch nose radius. A small nose radius concentrates strain at exactly the point that cracks. It is a tooling decision made before the die is cut, and the most expensive one to change afterwards.
  • Material condition. Grain direction, incoming hardness and how much cold work the strip already carries all change how far it stretches before it tears.
  • Lubrication and friction. Friction at the die radius raises the load the punch has to pull. A change of lubricant or a surface treatment on the blank can move a job from tearing to running.

Read the crack, not the description

Where the crack sits narrows the list before anyone touches the press. A crack that runs right through at the punch radius, all the way round, is a tensile failure - the material ran out of ductility. A crack on one side only usually points at alignment: punch-to-die clearance or an off-centre blank. Cracks at the flange, or a flange that comes out wavy, are a blank holder problem rather than a punch radius problem. That is why a photo of the failed part, and the station it failed at, is more useful than a description of the sound it made.

What has to be on the drawing

Two things prevent the argument. The first is the measurement position for wall thickness, because a drawn wall is a gradient and a crack is a thickness question - without a named position, three suppliers are comparing three different numbers. The second is whether the part is allowed a second draw. A part specified as a single draw may only be manufacturable in two, and that changes both the tooling cost and the piece price. Both are settled at quotation, not at tryout.

Key point

A crack at the punch radius is a tensile failure at the thinnest point of the wall. Check the draw ratio, then the punch radius, then material condition, then lubrication - in that order. The crack location tells you which one it is.

Frequently asked questions

What draw ratio can be done in one draw?

As a working guide: about 1.8-2.0 for low carbon steel, 1.6-1.8 for stainless steel and 1.8-2.0 for electrical pure iron. Those are starting points for a feasibility check, not a guarantee - the achievable ratio also depends on the punch radius, the lubricant and the material's incoming condition.

Does a bigger punch radius always help?

It reduces the strain at the nose, but it also changes the part: the radius is a dimension on the drawing, and a larger one can leave too little straight wall or a different bottom shape. The radius is usually fixed by the part, which is why the draw ratio is the lever that actually moves.

Can a crack be fixed by annealing?

Sometimes. An intermediate anneal between draws restores ductility, which is how a two-draw route with an anneal can produce a part that a single draw cannot. It adds a process step, so it belongs in the quoted route rather than in a tryout fix.

Is a crack always the material's fault?

No. The same coil that tears in one tool can run clean in another with a different punch radius, clearance or lubricant. That is why the tooling settings are checked before the material certificate.

Send The Drawing And We Will Run A Feasibility Check